Yardistry’s Meridian Gazebo Vs. Backyard Discovery’s Barrington Pavilion: Which is the Best Wooden Gazebo?

Header img

In the world of outdoor living spaces, the best wooden gazebo is a coveted title. Today, we will be putting two contenders head-to-head: Yardistry’s Meridian Gazebo and Backyard Discovery’s Barrington Pavilion. These structures are more than just beautiful additions to your backyard, they serve a functional purpose, providing shade and a gathering space for family and friends. Let’s delve into their respective features, pricing, and overall value to determine which of these gazebos reign supreme.

We don’t rate these Gazebos because they are virtually identical, and you won’t regret choosing one of them.

Yardistry’s Meridian Gazebo Backyard Discovery’s Barrington Pavilion
  • Type: Hard-top gazebo 
  • Dimensions, ft: 8′ x 8′, 10′ x10′, 10′ x 12′, 11′ x 13′, 12′ x 12′, 12′ x 14′, 12′ x 16′, 12′ x 20′, 12′ x 24
  • Material: Cedar wood + aluminum roof
  • Shape: Rectangle, Square
  • Included: anchors
  • Color: Cedar
  • Made: China
  • Type: Hard-top gazebo 
  • Dimensions, ft: 12′ x 10′, 14′ x 10′, 14′ x 12′, 16′ x 12′, 20′ x 12′
  • Material: Cedar wood + steel metal roof
  • Shape: Rectangle
  • Included: anchors, power port
  • Color: Cedar
  • Made: China
  • The first seller on the market
  • High-Quality
  • Customer service
  • Aluminum roof
  • More sizes variations
  • Faster assembly time
  • Less decor elements
  • No power port extra accessories available online
  • Less reviews
  • Not Certified for windstand
  • The reputable seller
  • High-Quality
  • Customer service
  • Steel roof
  • Less sizes variations
  • Slower Assembly time
  • More decor elements 
  • Power port included
  • No accessories
  • More reviews
  • Certified for windstand

Understanding the Basics

The Meridian Gazebo by Yardistry and the Barrington Pavilion by Backyard Discovery are cedar wood structures designed to enhance your outdoor living space. Each gazebo has its own unique attributes and design characteristics.

The Meridian gazebo from Yardistry comes in sizes 8′ x 8′, 10′ x10′, 10′ x 12′, 11′ x 13′, 12′ x 12′, 12′ x 14′, 12′ x 16′, 12′ x 20′, 12′ x 24. High-quality cedar wood, known for its durability and resistance to the elements, is used for construction. The roof is made of sturdy aluminum on a wood frame, ensuring durability and providing the shade you need to relax in nature. This gazebo will be the perfect addition to any deck, patio, or garden, enhancing the aesthetic look while providing a functional outdoor gathering place.

The Barrington Pavilion gazebo from Backyard Discovery, on the other hand, comes in a smaller variety of sizes: 12′ x 10′, 14′ x 10′, 14′ x 12′, 16′ x 12′, 20′ x 12′. This gazebo is also constructed of cedar wood but features a hip roof covered with a rigid metal roof. This design choice not only gives the gazebo architectural sophistication but also increases its durability, making it an all-weather structure. The gazebo has been tested and certified to withstand wind speeds of up to 100 miles per hour and can support up to 7,800 pounds, making it a safe and reliable choice for all conditions.

While both gazebos perform quite similarly — providing shade and creating an inviting outdoor space, materials, and construction — their design and specifications are slightly different. In the following sections, we’ll take a closer look at their durability, aesthetics, installation process, and value for money.

Strength and Durability

When evaluating the durability of these outdoor structures, we look at the quality of the material and any durability certifications provided by the manufacturer.

Yardistry’s Meridian gazebo boasts a sturdy cedar wood frame and a robust aluminum roof, giving confidence in its ability to withstand typical weather conditions.

However, the company does not provide any specific durability or wind resistance certifications for this product. Interestingly, both gazebos are virtually identical in construction, reflecting their similar durability characteristics. They utilize cedar, known for its natural resistance to rot, but diverge in their choice of roofing material.

In contrast, Backyard Discovery’s Barrington Pavilion goes further in demonstrating its durability. Its cedar wood frame is complemented by a sturdy steel metal roof that provides resistance to adverse weather conditions. Most importantly, Backyard Discovery provides special durability certifications for this gazebo. It is Pro-Tect certified, which proves its ability to withstand a 7,800-pound load or a 30-inch snow load. It has also been wind-tested and certified to withstand winds up to 100 miles per hour.

These certifications make the Barrington pavilion strong and durable, especially for those who live in regions that often experience heavy snowfall or high winds. Not only does this pavilion promise to be a stunning addition to your backyard, but it also guarantees safety and durability in a variety of weather conditions.

While both gazebos are built with quality materials, the Backyard Discovery provides an extra level of reassurance thanks to its durability certifications, making it a worthy choice for those who prioritize durability. Next, we’ll take a look at the aesthetic appeal of these two pergolas, as design can play a crucial role in improving the overall look of your outdoor space.

Aesthetics and Design

The visual appeal of a gazebo is a significant factor, considering it is a prominent feature in your outdoor space. Both Yardistry’s Meridian Gazebo and Backyard Discovery’s Barrington Pavilion carry a natural elegance of cedar wood, merging seamlessly with the greenery of your backyard.

The Meridian Gazebo by Yardistry encapsulates a sleek and contemporary aesthetic. The wooden structure, coupled with a minimalist silver aluminum roof, creates a visually appealing contrast. Its simple yet refined design can complement a wide range of outdoor decors, making it a versatile choice for homeowners.

On the other hand, the Barrington Pavilion from Backyard Discovery takes a more architecturally distinct approach. The uniqueness of its hip roof design, covered in a robust steel metal roof, exudes a sense of sophistication. The hard-top roof not only adds to the gazebo’s durability but also enhances its overall design appeal.

While both gazebos showcase the charm of natural cedar wood, they cater to different design preferences. The Meridian Gazebo offers a modern minimalist appeal, while the Barrington Pavilion carries a distinctive architectural character. It’s essential to choose a gazebo design that not only serves your functional needs but also resonates with your style and the aesthetic of your outdoor space.

Installation Process

While it is not immediately clear from the product description how complex the installation process of Yardistry’s Meridian Gazebo or Backyard Discovery’s Barrington Pavilion can be, it can be assumed that the assembly of these large structures is not a one-man job. One person can assemble all the elements, but it takes 4 people to install them. Given their size and heavy materials, it is recommended to enlist the help of a professional or at least a few capable hands to ensure safe and secure assembly.

Yardistry’s Meridian Gazebo — This structure features a sturdy aluminum roof, carrying heavy components, and maneuvering them into place can be a challenge. Similarly, the Barrington Pavilion, which has a sturdy steel metal roof, may require even more manpower and time to properly assemble. Likewise, a Barrington Pavilion has more fasteners and decorative elements, so assembly takes longer than a Yardistry.

It is also important to note that these gazebos must be securely anchored to withstand wind and weather conditions. This step is very important for both gazebos, especially the Barrington Pavilion, which is certified to withstand wind speeds of up to 100 miles per hour. Neglecting this step can jeopardize the stability and safety of your gazebo.

In addition to labor, the assembly process will require a variety of tools and equipment. It’s best to carefully review the manufacturer’s instructions and make sure you have everything you need on hand before you get started. Some manufacturers also offer customer support or assembly guides that can be helpful during the installation process.

These gazebos take 1 day to assemble, so we recommend hiring professionals. assembly prices start at $800 and go up to $2,500

Pricing and Value for Money

When considering the purchase of a gazebo, understanding the balance between cost and value is paramount. The Yardistry Meridian Gazebo and the Backyard Discovery Barrington Pavilion both present themselves as premium offerings in the gazebo market, with their price tags reflecting the quality, durability, and design sophistication they bring to your outdoor living space. Both brands are transparent about their pricing, which allows potential buyers to easily compare and contrast without the need to navigate through a complex buying process. This straightforward approach to pricing is beneficial for customers who prioritize budgeting and financial planning in their decision-making process. The comparable pricing of these gazebos suggests that either option could fit within similar budget ranges, choosing between them more a matter of personal preference and specific needs rather than cost alone. It’s important to note that while the initial purchase price is a significant factor, the value for money extends beyond this. The durable construction materials, such as cedar wood and, in the case of the Barrington Pavilion, a hard-top steel metal roof, mean that these gazebos are built to last. This durability translates to fewer replacements or repairs over time, contributing to the overall value of the investment. Additionally, the unique design features of each gazebo—whether it’s the sleek, contemporary look of the Yardistry Meridian or the architecturally distinct, robust design of the Backyard Discovery Barrington—add aesthetic value to your property, which can be just as important as their functional benefits. Ultimately, the decision between these two gazebos should consider not only their purchase price but also the long-term value they add to your home and outdoor living experience. Whether it’s the modern elegance of the Yardistry Gazebo or the certified strength and durability of the Backyard Discovery Pavilion, each offers a compelling value proposition for the discerning homeowner.

The Most Important Difference I’ve Found

One of the most important distinctions that sets Yardistry apart from the competition for the best wooden gazebo is the extensive range of accessories that Backyard Discovery can’t match. But accessories do not come standard. At Yardistry, they understand that a gazebo is not just a structure, but a living space that reflects the lifestyle and needs of the homeowner. To that end, they offer many additional elements designed to enhance the usability and enjoyment of pergolas. For those who like to entertain, a barstool can transform the space into an inviting place to sit. For insect protection, a mosquito net is an indispensable accessory to ensure comfort and pest-free evenings spent outdoors. Privacy issues are solved with a partition that allows privacy for relaxation or conversation. In addition, to effectively manage rainwater, a gutter kit can be incorporated into the structure to prevent water accumulation and protect the integrity of the wooden pergola. All of these accessories not only enhance the functionality of Yardistry gazebos but also allow them to be customized to the homeowner’s specific wants and needs, making them one of the best options in the wood gazebo market.

Concluding Thoughts

Choosing between the Meridian Gazebo from Yardistry and the Barrington Pavilion from Backyard Discovery can be a difficult choice, as both are priced competitively. I can’t tell you which is better, you won’t go wrong with either choice:

  • Proven sellers
  • Long time on the market
  • Practically the same design, a little difference in color, in roof material
  • Barrington Pavilion from Backyard Discovery has more small parts, but it is an amateur, some will like it, some will not. but because of the small parts is more difficult to assemble.
  • Yardistry is a mastodon in the market of wooden gazebos, their brand is one of the first. Backyard Discovery started producing gazebos much later, but they have aggressively entered the market.
  • Barrington Pavilion offers special durability certifications, but the construction is the same and I don’t think Yardistry is inferior.
  • Clear pricing and payment flexibility.
  • An aluminized roof is more durable than a steel roof, but they will last 25 years and I wouldn’t lean on that figure.
  • The roofs on both gazebos are not airtight enough and can leak in heavy rain. but they are not designed to last that long
  • Cedar needs to be treated every 3 years because it loses its look in the sun
  • One of the advantages of Yardistry is that they sell gazebo accessories, which Backyard does not.

Essentially, both of these designs can transform your backyard into a functional and aesthetically pleasing space for outdoor living. The final choice will depend on which gazebo best suits your specific requirements and aesthetic preferences. No matter what choice you make, any of these pergolas are sure to add elegance and functionality to your backyard.

About Author

The author, Aliaksandr Kozel, of this blog post, is not a singular entity but rather a team of seasoned professionals who bring a wealth of experience and skill to the table as handymen. Each team member is dedicated to offering clients only the highest quality of service, ensuring that every project, regardless of its size or complexity, is handled with utmost care and precision. Our handymen are not only adept in their craftsmanship but are also fully equipped with the latest in tools and technology. This state-of-the-art equipment allows them to execute any given project efficiently, be it a simple repair or a complex outdoor gazebo installation. Their broad skill set and access to modern tools enable them to address a wide range of home improvement needs, promising results that not only meet but often exceed expectations. With a passion for their craft and a commitment to excellence, our team is prepared to tackle any challenge, ensuring that your vision for your space is brought to life with professionalism and expertise.


How often does each gazebo require maintenance over time? arrow

Care of each gazebo includes periodic inspections and cleaning to maintain the quality of the wood; however, the cedar wood that both gazebos are made of naturally resists rot, minimizing maintenance efforts.

To keep the appearance, the wood can be treated with Seal every 3-5 years.

Will the gazebo withstand extreme weather conditions such as high winds or heavy snowfall? arrow

The gazebos are designed almost identically, so the Yardistry will have similar characteristics as the Backyard.

In terms of load capacity, the Backyard Discovery Barrington Pavilion has been certified to withstand up to 7,800 pounds, demonstrating its superior structural integrity. Both gazebos are designed to withstand adverse weather conditions, with the Barrington Pavilion specifically certified to withstand winds up to 100 miles per hour and significant snow loads, making it exceptionally stable.

Is there a difference in the level of privacy provided by each of the gazebos? arrow

In terms of privacy, the design of each gazebo affects the level of privacy. While the basic designs inherently do not provide privacy, Yardistry offers customizable options, such as privacy walls, that can increase the level of privacy.

How do the warranties on each pergola compare? arrow

Finally, warranties on each gazebo can vary, so it is recommended that you contact the manufacturers directly for the most accurate and up-to-date warranty information so that you are fully informed about protecting your investment over time.

Find out the cost of the assembly service for this item in your state from our handyman company.
  • 500+ fulfilled projects
  • 15+ years of experience
  • 4.9 stars average rating
and other skilled handymen in Kozel LLC
Get a quote
Your message has been sent

Thank you for your inquiry. We will be contacting you shortly to finalise it!